A common way to establish an IPsec tunnel on Linux is to use an IKE daemon, like the one from the strongSwan project, with a minimal configuration:1

conn V2-1  left        = 2001:db8:1::1  leftsubnet  = 2001:db8:a1::/64  right       = 2001:db8:2::1  rightsubnet = 2001:db8:a2::/64  authby      = psk  auto        = route

The same configuration can be used on both sides. Each side will figure out if it is “left” or “right.” The IPsec site-to-site tunnel endpoints are 2001:db8:?1::1 and 2001:db8:?2::1. The protected subnets are 2001:db8:?a1::/64 and 2001:db8:?a2::/64. As a result, strongSwanconfigures the following policies in the kernel:

$ ip xfrm policysrc 2001:db8:a1::/64 dst 2001:db8:a2::/64        dir out priority 399999 ptype main        tmpl src 2001:db8:1::1 dst 2001:db8:2::1                proto esp reqid 4 mode tunnelsrc 2001:db8:a2::/64 dst 2001:db8:a1::/64        dir fwd priority 399999 ptype main        tmpl src 2001:db8:2::1 dst 2001:db8:1::1                proto esp reqid 4 mode tunnelsrc 2001:db8:a2::/64 dst 2001:db8:a1::/64        dir in priority 399999 ptype main        tmpl src 2001:db8:2::1 dst 2001:db8:1::1                proto esp reqid 4 mode tunnel[…]

This kind of IPsec tunnel is a policy-based VPN: encapsulation and decapsulation are governed by these policies. Each of them contains the following elements:

• a direction (out, in or fwd2),

• a selector (source subnet, destination subnet, protocol, ports),

• a mode (transport or tunnel),

• an encapsulation protocol (esp or ah), and

• the endpoint source and destination addresses.

When a matching policy is found, the kernel will look for a corresponding security association (using reqid and the endpoint source and destination addresses):

$ ip xfrm statesrc 2001:db8:1::1 dst 2001:db8:2::1        proto esp spi 0xc1890b6e reqid 4 mode tunnel        replay-window 0 flag af-unspec        auth-trunc hmac(sha256) 0x5b68[…]8ba2904 128        enc cbc(aes) 0x8e0e377ad8fd91e8553648340ff0fa06        anti-replay context: seq 0x0, oseq 0x0, bitmap 0x00000000[…]

If no security association is found, the packet is put on hold and the IKE daemon is asked to negotiate an appropriate one. Otherwise, the packet is encapsulated. The receiving end identifies the appropriate security association using the SPI in the header. Two security associations are needed to establish a bidirectionnal tunnel:

$ tcpdump -pni eth0 -c2 -s0 esp13:07:30.871150 IP6 2001:db8:1::1 > 2001:db8:2::1: ESP(spi=0xc1890b6e,seq=0x222)13:07:30.872297 IP6 2001:db8:2::1 > 2001:db8:1::1: ESP(spi=0xcf2426b6,seq=0x204)

All IPsec implementations are compatible with policy-based VPNs. However, some configurations are difficult to implement. For example, consider the following proposition for redundant site-to-site VPNs:

A possible configuration between V1-1 and V2-1 could be:

conn V1-1-to-V2-1  left        = 2001:db8:1::1  leftsubnet  = 2001:db8:a1::/64,2001:db8:a6::cc:1/128,2001:db8:a6::cc:5/128  right       = 2001:db8:2::1  rightsubnet = 2001:db8:a2::/64,2001:db8:a6::/64,2001:db8:a8::/64  authby      = psk  keyexchange = ikev2  auto        = route

Each time a subnet is modified on one site, the configurations need to be updated on all sites. Moreover, overlapping subnets (2001:db8:?a6::/64 on one side and 2001:db8:?a6::cc:1/128 at the other) can also be problematic.

The alternative is to use route-based VPNs: any packet traversing a pseudo-interface will be encapsulated using a security policy bound to the interface. This brings two features:

1. Routing daemons can be used to distribute routes to be protected by the VPN. This decreases the administrative burden when many subnets are present on each side.

2. Encapsulation and decapsulation can be executed in a different routing instance or namespace. This enables a clean separation between a private routing instance (where VPN users are) and a public routing instance (where VPN endpoints are).

Route-based VPN on Juniper

Before looking at how to achieve that on Linux, let’s have a look at the way it works with a JunOS-based platform (like a Juniper vSRX). This platform as long-standing history of supporting route-based VPNs (a feature already present in the Netscreen ISG platform).

Let’s assume we want to configure the IPsec VPN from V3-2 to V1-1. First, we need to configure the tunnel interface and bind it to the “private” routing instance containing only internal routes (with IPv4, they would have been RFC?1918 routes):

interfaces {
    st0 {
        unit 1 {
            family inet6 {
                address 2001:db8:ff::7/127;
            }
        }
    }}routing-instances {
    private {
        instance-type virtual-router;        interface st0.1;    }}

The second step is to configure the VPN:

security {
    /* Phase 1 configuration */
    ike {
        proposal IKE-P1 {
            authentication-method pre-shared-keys;
            dh-group group20;
            encryption-algorithm aes-256-gcm;        }
        policy IKE-V1-1 {
            mode main;
            proposals IKE-P1;
            pre-shared-key ascii-text "d8bdRxaY22oH1j89Z2nATeYyrXfP9ga6xC5mi0RG1uc";
        }
        gateway GW-V1-1 {
            ike-policy IKE-V1-1;
            address 2001:db8:1::1;
            external-interface lo0.1;
            general-ikeid;
            version v2-only;        }
    }
    /* Phase 2 configuration */
    ipsec {
        proposal ESP-P2 {
            protocol esp;
            encryption-algorithm aes-256-gcm;        }
        policy IPSEC-V1-1 {
            perfect-forward-secrecy keys group20;
            proposals ESP-P2;        }
        vpn VPN-V1-1 {            bind-interface st0.1;            df-bit copy;
            ike {
                gateway GW-V1-1;
                ipsec-policy IPSEC-V1-1;            }
            establish-tunnels on-traffic;        }
    }}

We get a route-based VPN because we bind the st0.1 interface to the VPN-V1-1 VPN. Once the VPN is up, any packet entering st0.1 will be encapsulated and sent to the 2001:db8:?1::1endpoint.

The last step is to configure BGP in the “private” routing instance to exchange routes with the remote site:

routing-instances {
    private {
        routing-options {
            router-id 1.0.3.2;
            maximum-paths 16;
        }
        protocols {
            bgp {
                preference 140;
                log-updown;
                group v4-VPN {
                    type external;
                    local-as 65003;
                    hold-time 6;
                    neighbor 2001:db8:ff::6 peer-as 65001;
                    multipath;
                    export [ NEXT-HOP-SELF OUR-ROUTES NOTHING ];                }
            }
        }
    }}

The export filter OUR-ROUTES needs to select the routes to be advertised to the other peers. For example:

policy-options {
    policy-statement OUR-ROUTES {
        term 10 {
            from {
                protocol ospf3;
                route-type internal;            }
            then {
                metric 0;
                accept;            }
        }
    }}

The configuration needs to be repeated for the other peers. The complete version is available on GitHub. Once the BGP sessions are up, we start learning routes from the other sites. For example, here is the route for 2001:db8:?a1::/64:

> show route 2001:db8:a1::/64 protocol bgp table private.inet6.0 best-pathprivate.inet6.0: 15 destinations, 19 routes (15 active, 0 holddown, 0 hidden)+ = Active Route, - = Last Active, * = Both2001:db8:a1::/64   *[BGP/140] 01:12:32, localpref 100, from 2001:db8:ff::6                      AS path: 65001 I, validation-state: unverified                      to 2001:db8:ff::6 via st0.1                    > to 2001:db8:ff::14 via st0.2

It was learnt both from V1-1 (through st0.1) and V1-2 (through st0.2). The route is part of the private routing instance but encapsulated packets are sent/received in the public routing instance. No route-leaking is needed for this configuration. The VPN cannot be used as a gateway from internal hosts to external hosts (or vice-versa). This could also have been done with JunOS’ security policies (stateful firewall rules) but doing the separation with routing instances also ensure routes from different domains are not mixed and a simple policy misconfiguration won’t lead to a disaster.

Route-based VPN on Linux

Starting from Linux?3.15, a similar configuration is possible with the help of a virtual tunnel interface.3 First, we create the “private” namespace:

# ip netns add private# ip netns exec private sysctl -qw net.ipv6.conf.all.forwarding=1

Any “private” interface needs to be moved to this namespace (no IP is configured as we can use IPv6 link-local addresses):

# ip link set netns private dev eth1# ip link set netns private dev eth2# ip netns exec private ip link set up dev eth1# ip netns exec private ip link set up dev eth2

Then, we create vti6, a tunnel interface (similar to st0.1 in the JunOS example):

# ip -6 tunnel add vti6 \
   mode vti6 \
   local 2001:db8:1::1 \
   remote 2001:db8:3::2 \   key 6# ip link set netns private dev vti6# ip netns exec private ip addr add 2001:db8:ff::6/127 dev vti6# ip netns exec private sysctl -qw net.ipv4.conf.vti6.disable_policy=1# ip netns exec private ip link set vti6 mtu 1500# ip netns exec private ip link set vti6 up

The tunnel interface is created in the initial namespace and moved to the “private” one. It will remember its original namespace where it will process encapsulated packets. Any packet entering the interface will temporarily get a firewall mark of 6 that will be used only to match the appropriate IPsec policy4 below. The kernel sets a low MTU on the interface to handle any possible combination of ciphers and protocols. We set it to 1500 and let PMTUDdo its work.

We can then configure strongSwan:5

conn V3-2  left        = 2001:db8:1::1  leftsubnet  = ::/0  right       = 2001:db8:3::2  rightsubnet = ::/0  authby      = psk  mark        = 6  auto        = route  keyexchange = ikev2  keyingtries = %forever  ike         = aes256gcm16-prfsha384-ecp384!  esp         = aes256gcm16-prfsha384-ecp384!  mobike      = no

The IKE daemon configures the following policies in the kernel:

$ ip xfrm policysrc ::/0 dst ::/0        dir out priority 399999 ptype main        mark 0x6/0xffffffff        tmpl src 2001:db8:1::1 dst 2001:db8:3::2                proto esp reqid 1 mode tunnelsrc ::/0 dst ::/0        dir fwd priority 399999 ptype main        mark 0x6/0xffffffff        tmpl src 2001:db8:3::2 dst 2001:db8:1::1                proto esp reqid 1 mode tunnelsrc ::/0 dst ::/0        dir in priority 399999 ptype main        mark 0x6/0xffffffff        tmpl src 2001:db8:3::2 dst 2001:db8:1::1                proto esp reqid 1 mode tunnel[…]

These policies are used for any source or destination as long as the firewall mark is equal to 6, which matches the mark configured for the tunnel interface.

The last step is to configure BGP to exchange routes. We can use BIRD for this:

router id 1.0.1.1;protocol device {
   scan time 10;}protocol kernel {
   persist;
   learn;
   import all;
   export all;
   merge paths yes;}protocol bgp IBGP_V3_2 {
   local 2001:db8:ff::6 as 65001;
   neighbor 2001:db8:ff::7 as 65003;
   import all;
   export where ifname ~ "eth*";
   preference 160;
   hold time 6;}

Once BIRD is started in the “private” namespace, we can check routes are learned correctly:

$ ip netns exec private ip -6 route show 2001:db8:a3::/642001:db8:a3::/64 proto bird metric 1024        nexthop via 2001:db8:ff::5  dev vti5 weight 1        nexthop via 2001:db8:ff::7  dev vti6 weight 1

The above route was learnt from both V3-1 (through vti5) and V3-2 (through vti6). Like for the JunOS version, there is no route-leaking between the “private” namespace and the initial one. The VPN cannot be used as a gateway between the two namespaces, only for encapsulation. This also prevent a misconfiguration (for example, IKE daemon not running) from allowing packets to leave the private network.

As a bonus, unencrypted traffic can be observed with tcpdump on the tunnel interface:

$ ip netns exec private tcpdump -pni vti6 icmp6tcpdump: verbose output suppressed, use -v or -vv for full protocol decodelistening on vti6, link-type LINUX_SLL (Linux cooked), capture size 262144 bytes20:51:15.258708 IP6 2001:db8:a1::1 > 2001:db8:a3::1: ICMP6, echo request, seq 6920:51:15.260874 IP6 2001:db8:a3::1 > 2001:db8:a1::1: ICMP6, echo reply, seq 69

You can find all the configuration files for this example on GitHub. The documentation of strongSwan also features a page about route-based VPNs. It is possible to replace IPsec by WireGuard, a fast and modern VPN implementation.